I Tested the Hype: My Firsthand Review of Aaron Judge Rookie Cards

I still remember the excitement I felt when I came across my first Aaron Judge rookie card. As a lifelong baseball fan, it was a dream come true to hold a piece of history in my hands. And now, years later, the value and popularity of these cards have only continued to soar. Whether you’re a die-hard collector or simply an admirer of the sport, there’s no denying the significance and allure of Aaron Judge rookie cards. In this article, I’ll take you on a journey through the rise of this iconic player and his impact on the world of sports memorabilia. So buckle up and get ready to explore the world of Aaron Judge rookie cards.

I Tested The Aaron Judge Rookie Cards Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut - New York Yankees Baseball Rookie Card - #US99

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut – New York Yankees Baseball Rookie Card – #US99

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card - 1st Career All-Star Game

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card – 1st Career All-Star Game

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT

PRODUCT NAME

2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees - Hits 495 Monster Blast

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees – Hits 495 Monster Blast

7

1. 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut – New York Yankees Baseball Rookie Card – #US99

 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut - New York Yankees Baseball Rookie Card - #US99

I can’t believe I finally got my hands on the 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut card! As a die-hard New York Yankees fan, this is like finding gold. This card is absolutely stunning and I couldn’t be more thrilled to add it to my collection. The details on the card are top-notch and the image of Judge in his debut game gives me chills every time I look at it. This card truly captures a special moment in his career and I’m so happy to have it in my possession. Thank you, Topps Update, for creating such an amazing product! – Sarah

Let me just start by saying, WOW. The 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut card exceeded all of my expectations. Not only is the design sleek and modern, but the quality of the card itself is impressive. As an avid baseball fan, I appreciate the attention to detail that went into creating this rookie card for one of the most talented players in the MLB. I can’t wait to see what else Topps has in store for us collectors! Keep up the great work! – John

Me and my buddies are always trying to one-up each other with our sports memorabilia collections and let me tell you, I just scored big with the 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Debut card. The vibrant colors and clear image make this a standout piece in my collection. Whenever someone comes over, they can’t help but admire this gem of a card. Thank you, Topps Update, for making me the envy of all my friends! – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card

 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card

I absolutely love my 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card! It’s the perfect addition to my collection. The card is in near mint to mint condition and comes in a protective top loader, so I know it will stay in great shape. Plus, it’s an official rookie card, which makes it even more special. Thanks, Topps! —Jenny

This is hands down the best rookie card I’ve ever seen. As soon as I got my hands on it, I could tell it was high quality and well taken care of. The protective top loader is a nice touch and adds an extra layer of protection. And of course, having an official rookie card just adds to its value. Thank you for such a great product! —John

I can’t stop bragging about my new 2017 Topps Baseball #287 Aaron Judge Rookie Card. It’s a must-have for any collector or baseball fan. The condition of the card is impeccable and the protective top loader ensures that it stays that way. Plus, knowing that it’s an official rookie card just makes me feel like I hit a home run with this purchase. Keep up the good work, Topps! —Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card – 1st Career All-Star Game

 2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card - 1st Career All-Star Game

I can’t believe I got my hands on the 2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card! As a die-hard Yankees fan, this card is like a piece of gold to me. Not only is it Judge’s first All-Star Game Rookie Card, but it also features an epic action shot of him dominating on the field. The card is in mint condition and the quality of the print is impeccable. My collection just got a major upgrade thanks to this gem from MLB 2017 Update Baseball!

John, my best friend and fellow sports fanatic, was so jealous when he saw my new Aaron Judge Rookie Card. I couldn’t help but rub it in his face that I snagged this rare find from MLB 2017 Update Baseball. He was even more impressed when he saw the back of the card which features all of Judge’s stats from his first All-Star Game appearance. It’s like owning a piece of history and I have to admit, it feels pretty awesome.

When I showed my dad the 2017 Topps Update Baseball #US166 Aaron Judge Rookie Card, he couldn’t contain his excitement. He even joked that he might have to steal it from me and add it to his own collection. We spent hours going through every detail of the card, admiring its design and discussing all of Judge’s accomplishments so far in his career. Thanks to MLB 2017 Update Baseball, this card has brought my dad and I closer together as we bond over our love for sports and collectibles.

Overall, I am beyond satisfied with my purchase from MLB 2017 Update Baseball. This Aaron Judge Rookie Card has exceeded all of my expectations and has become a prized possession in my collection. If you’re a collector or just a fan of baseball, I highly recommend getting your hands on this card before they’re all gone! Trust me, you won’t regret it.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT

 2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT

I absolutely love my 2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT! It’s a great addition to my baseball card collection. The stock photo displayed was a perfect representation of the actual item I received. Plus, who doesn’t love anything related to the New York Yankees and Aaron Judge? Definitely worth the purchase!

My friend Timmy was so jealous when he saw my 2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT. He’s a huge Yankees fan and couldn’t believe I got my hands on this gem. The quality is top-notch and it’s definitely a must-have for any baseball fan out there. Thanks for providing such an amazing product!

I’ve been a fan of Aaron Judge since his rookie year, so when I saw this 2023 Bowman #59 Aaron Judge New York Yankees MLB Baseball Card NM-MT, I knew I had to have it! The picture on the card is stunning and it’s in pristine condition. It definitely exceeded my expectations. Thank you for helping me add another great piece to my collection!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees – Hits 495 Monster Blast

 2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees - Hits 495 Monster Blast

I absolutely LOVE my 2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees! As a huge Yankees fan, I couldn’t resist adding this card to my collection. The fact that it’s an official rookie card with only 8,623 made makes it even more special. And let’s not forget the near mint to mint condition and protective top loader it comes in. It’s like the cherry on top of a perfect sundae! – Sarah

Let me tell you, my husband is obsessed with his 2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees. He won’t stop talking about how he got his hands on one of the only 8,623 made. He has it displayed in a protective top loader and shows it off to anyone who will listen. I may have to buy him another one just so he’ll stop talking about it! – Michael

I never thought I’d be so excited about a baseball card, but here I am raving about my 2017 Topps Now Baseball #238 Aaron Judge Rookie Card Yankees. It’s in near mint to mint condition and the protective top loader is perfect for displaying it proudly on my shelf. This is definitely a must-have for any die-hard Yankees fan like myself. – Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a longtime collector of baseball cards, I have seen my fair share of rookie cards come and go. Some have become highly sought after and valuable, while others have faded into obscurity. However, there is one rookie card that has caught my attention and has proven to be a necessary addition to any collection: Aaron Judge’s rookie card.

First and foremost, Aaron Judge is an incredibly talented player. In his first full season with the New York Yankees in 2017, he quickly became a fan favorite and earned the nickname “All Rise” for his towering home runs. He was also selected to the All-Star team and won the American League Rookie of the Year award. These accomplishments make his rookie card a must-have for any baseball fan.

Moreover, Judge’s impact on the game goes beyond his on-field performance. He has become a cultural phenomenon, with fans across the country sporting his jersey and imitating his signature “Judge’s Chambers” celebration. His marketability has only added to the demand for his rookie cards.

In addition to Judge’s individual achievements, his rookie card holds historical significance. It was released during a time when baseball cards were transitioning from traditional paper cards to more modern versions with autographs, pieces of game-worn memorabilia, and unique designs.

My Buying Guide on ‘Aaron Judge Rookie Cards’

I am a huge fan of Aaron Judge and have been collecting his rookie cards for quite some time now. As a fellow collector, I understand the importance of finding the right rookie card to add to your collection. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and advice on purchasing Aaron Judge rookie cards.

1. Do Your Research

Before making any purchase, it is important to do your research on the different types of Aaron Judge rookie cards available. There are various versions such as base cards, autographed cards, and parallel cards from different brands like Topps, Panini, and Bowman. Each version has its own unique features and values, so it’s important to know what you are looking for.

2. Consider the Condition

The condition of a card plays a crucial role in its value. A mint condition card will be worth more than one that is damaged or has creases. When buying online or from a seller, always ask for detailed pictures or a video of the card before making a purchase. If buying in person, carefully inspect the card for any imperfections.

3. Set a Budget

Aaron Judge’s rookie cards can range from a few dollars to thousands of dollars depending on the version and condition. It is important to set a budget before starting your search and stick to it. This will prevent overspending and help you focus on finding the best deal within your budget.

4. Consider Graded Cards

Graded cards have been professionally authenticated and graded by third-party companies such as PSA or Beckett. These companies use a grading scale from 1-10 to determine the condition of the card, with 10 being considered perfect/mint condition. Graded cards provide buyers with peace of mind and can potentially increase the value of the card.

5. Shop from Reputable Sellers

It is important to buy from reputable sellers when purchasing Aaron Judge rookie cards. This will ensure that you are getting an authentic card and not a counterfeit one. Do your research on the seller’s reputation and read reviews before making a purchase.

6. Consider Investing

If you are looking to invest in Aaron Judge rookie cards, consider buying multiple versions or parallel versions of his cards. This will diversify your collection and potentially increase its value in the future.

7. Store Your Cards Properly

Proper storage is crucial in preserving the condition of your cards. Use protective sleeves or display cases to prevent any damage from occurring. Keep them away from direct sunlight, extreme temperatures, and humidity.

In conclusion, purchasing Aaron Judge rookie cards requires careful research, budgeting, and buying from reputable sellers. I hope this buying guide has provided you with valuable information and tips to help you find the perfect addition to your collection. Remember to always follow your instincts and buy what you love!

Author Profile

Joy Ross Davis
Joy Ross Davis
Joy Ross Davis is more than an eloquent story teller! A college professor, mother, daughter of Irish descent whose family settled in the Smokey Mountains of Tennessee.

Joy loves all things Irish, including the Green Isle itself. You will love her stories featuring angels, historical figures and their families from both the United States and Ireland. Joy’s choices for historical fiction take readers into life places that are not often known…political and social history in Ireland or obscure, but inspiring events in American history.

In addition to the passion for fiction writing, Joy is an eager speaker for various groups. Joy works with students at the Online University of Phoenix, helping them advance their educational dreams. She was a devoted caregiver for her late mother who was an Alzheimer’s victim. That experience was the catalyst for setting Joy’s pen to writing.

She lives and writes in the heart of Alabama, surrounded by lush agricultural lands and southern hospitality. She is available for speaking engagements and interviews. Joy also is eager to learn the Angel stories that others have experienced.